Learning Pathways within the Multiplicative Conceptual Field - Insights Reflected through a Rasch Measurement Framework

von: Caroline Long

Waxmann Verlag GmbH, 2015

ISBN: 9783830982890 , 248 Seiten

Format: PDF, OL

Kopierschutz: frei

Windows PC,Mac OSX Apple iPad, Android Tablet PC's Online-Lesen für: Windows PC,Mac OSX,Linux

Preis: 35,99 EUR

Mehr zum Inhalt

Learning Pathways within the Multiplicative Conceptual Field - Insights Reflected through a Rasch Measurement Framework


 

Buchtitel

1

Abstract

7

Acknowledgements

11

Prologue

13

Table of contents

17

1 A prospective pathway for meeting mathematics education challenges

19

1.1 Mathematical knowledge

19

1.1.1 Towards a framework

20

1.2 Theoretical framework

21

1.2.1 Theory of conceptual fields

21

1.2.2 Educational measurement

23

1.3 Problem statement

24

1.3.1 Global concern over mathematics education

24

1.3.2 Perceived factors influencing under-performance

25

1.4 Research focus

27

1.4.1 Research questions

28

1.4.2 Research design

30

1.4.3 Literature review

30

1.4.4 Investigation of the multiplicative conceptual field

32

1.5 Summary: A prospective pathway

34

2 Threshold concepts in the unfolding number systems

35

2.1 From intuitive notions into explicit knowledge

35

2.1.1 Research questions

37

2.2 Epistemological context

37

2.3 Unfolding number systems

38

2.3.1 From number sense to a number system

39

2.3.2 Natural number systems

41

2.3.3 Integers

42

2.3.4 Rational number system

42

2.3.5 Real number system

43

2.3.6 Complex number system

43

2.3.7 Algebra

44

2.4 Summary: Central factors in mathematical development

44

3 Theory of conceptual fields: Essential domains informing teaching and learning

46

3.1 Embracing the complexity in learning mathematics

46

3.1.1 Components of the theory

47

3.1.2 Research questions

48

3.2 Conceptual domain

49

3.2.1 Mathematical concept as a “triple of sets”

49

3.2.2 Conceptual fields

50

3.2.3 Some factors in development of mathematics knowledge

51

3.3 Cognitive domain

52

3.3.1 The subject and the external world

52

3.3.2 Operational-structural relations

54

3.3.3 Threshold concepts

55

3.3.4 From schemes and situations to generalisable concepts

55

3.3.5 An integration of key ideas

57

3.4 Didactic domain

58

3.4.1 Nurturing the learning process

58

3.4.2 The teacher’s role

59

3.5 Semiotic domain

59

3.5.1 The status of knowledge

59

3.5.2 Developmental stages towards greater abstraction

60

3.5.3 Language, an elaborated social system

60

3.5.4 Summary: Language precision and mathematics

61

3.6 Evaluative domain

61

3.6.1 Assessment for learning

62

3.7 Summary: Consequences for educational research and measurement

62

4 Assessment and measurement: A discussion of core requirements

65

4.1 From mathematics to measurement

65

4.1.1 Research questions

65

4.1.2 Large-scale assessment and learning

67

4.2 A theory of mathematics assessment

68

4.2.1 Conceptions of mathematics

68

4.2.2 Critical elements for the formulation of an assessment programme

69

4.2.3 Core notions for assessment

72

4.3 Measurement and the Rasch model

72

4.3.1 Measurement

73

4.3.2 Mathematical models

75

4.3.3 The development of the Rasch model

76

4.3.4 Validity

81

4.3.5 Reliability

82

4.3.6 Core ideas underpinning the Rasch model

82

4.4 Validity of assessment practices

83

5 The multiplicative conceptual field

85

5.1 Mathematical structure and developmental consequences

85

5.1.1 Research questions

86

5.2 Multiplication and division

87

5.2.1 Problem situations

87

5.2.2 Extension to rational numbers

89

5.2.3 Multiplicative structures

90

5.2.4 Building the base for rational number

97

5.3 Rational number

97

5.3.1 Rational number sub constructs

97

5.3.2 Operations on fractions

103

5.3.3 Synthesis of rational number

104

5.3.4 Proportional reasoning

105

5.3.5 Functional relationship and link to calculus

108

5.3.6 Considering salient features

109

5.4 Percent

110

5.4.1 Mathematical Structure

111

5.4.2 The language of percent

114

5.4.3 Tasks and problems

115

5.4.4 A concise language with important consequences

116

5.5 Probability

117

5.5.1 Mathematical structure

117

5.5.2 Historical factors

118

5.5.3 The acquisition of probabilistic concepts

118

5.5.4 A distinctive reasoning

118

5.6 Proficiency in the multiplicative conceptual field

118

5.7 Summary: Didactic implications, assessment and research

120

6 Exploration of data within the Rasch measurement framework

122

6.1 Understanding complexity through application of the Rasch model

122

6.1.1 Research questions

122

6.2 Methodology for the empirical investigation

122

6.2.1 Test development within a Rasch measurement framework

123

6.2.2 Participants

123

6.2.3 Test formulation

124

6.2.4 Test situation, administration and scoring

126

6.2.5 Data Analysis

127

6.3 Analytic framework for item analysis

135

6.3.1 Contextual factors

136

6.3.2 Type of situation

136

6.3.3 Mathematical structure

137

6.3.4 Mode of representation

138

6.3.5 Number range and value

138

6.3.6 Response processes and procedures

139

6.4 Item analysis

140

6.4.1 Item by strand analysis

142

6.5 Fraction item analysis

143

6.5.1 Critical findings: Fraction items at Levels 1, 2, 3 and 4

146

6.6 Ratio, proportion and rate item analysis

148

6.6.1 Critical findings: Ratio, rate and proportion items at Levels 1 to 7

150

6.7 Percent item analysis

153

6.7.1 Critical findings: Percent items at Levels 2, 3, 4, and 7

155

6.8 Probability item analysis

157

6.8.1 Critical findings: Probability items at Levels 2, 3 and 4

159

6.9 Pre-Algebra item analysis

161

6.9.1 Critical findings: Pre-Algebra items at Levels 2, 3, 4 and 5

163

6.10 Summary descriptions at Levels 1 to 7

165

6.10.1 Critical points and threshold concepts

170

6.10.4 Reflections and further insights

171

7 Identifying threshold concepts in reasoning behind item responses

172

7.1 Tracking learner competences

172

7.1.1 Research questions

173

7.2 Research method

173

7.3 Framework for interview analyses

177

7.4 High proficiency learners

182

7.4.1 Levels 6 and 7: Adele (School A), Anna (School B)

182

7.4.2 Level 5: Kelly, Jane, Angela, Carla (School A), Prinella (School B)

186

7.4.3 Proficiency exhibited at Levels 5, 6 and 7

194

7.5 Middle-high proficiency

196

7.5.1 Level 4, Thembani and Sipho (School B)

196

7.5.2 Level 4: Shiluba, Carola, Linda and Kate (School A)

199

7.5.3 Proficiency exhibited at Level 4

205

7.6 Middle-low proficiency

206

7.6.1 Level 3, Phaphama, Maria, Mpho (School B)

206

7.6.2 Level 3: Cheryl and Zanele (School A)

211

7.6.3 Proficiency exhibited at Level 3

215

7.7 Low proficiency

216

7.7.1 Level 1: Mishack, Amukelani and Mahesh (School B)

216

7.7.2 Proficiency exhibited at Level 1

218

7.8 Overview of four proficiency levels

219

7.9 Theoretical insights from the theory of conceptual fields

221

7.10 Recommendations for the instrument

222

7.11 Reflections on the interviews

223

8 Addressing complexity: Implications for curriculum, teaching and assessment

224

8.1 Answering Poincaré

224

8.2 Insights from the theory of conceptual fields

224

8.3 Insights from the perspective of assessment and measurement

225

8.3.1 Rasch analysis and the theory of conceptual fields

226

8.3.2 Person-item map

226

8.3.3 Cognitive and pedagogical insights

227

8.4 Implications for curriculum, teaching and research

227

8.4.1 Levels of development

228

8.4.2 Identifying threshold concepts

230

8.5 Reflections and limitations

232

8.5.1 Instrument development recommendations

232

8.5.2 Limitations of the study

233

8.6 Future Research

235

8.7 Conclusion

236

9 References

238

List of Abbreviations

245

List of Figures

246

List of Tables

247